Is Alan Pardew's spell as Crystal Palace manager starting to mirror his time at Newcastle?

Written by Jamie Smith

Newcastle fan and writer Jamie Smith guests on FYP this week with some background to how things unravelled for Alan Pardew at St James' Park. Read on to see if any of this sounds familiar, Palace fans.

Greetings from Newcastle.

I'm sure that's a statement you all will, at the very least, treat with suspicion given the obvious and somewhat prickly recent connection between our clubs, but rest assured I come in peace. However, it is that very connection that has prompted me to write to another clubs fanzine, if nothing else to add a bit of perspective. I hope your readers will hear me out, maybe even start understand things from our perspective a little.

It seems a bit unsavoury that the #Pardewout hashtag gradually reappearing on social media is apparently so heavily favoured by Newcastle fans (from my observations) and it can appear to be lacking in class somewhat, not to mention hypocritical given our own struggles and current perilous position. However, there is an obvious element of discomfort amongst Palace fans about the recent 10-game winless run that may prompt a re-examination of the facts in the ongoing "dialogue" regarding the managerial credentials of Alan Pardew.

I have been tempted to write this before, but I feel the time is out right now given that certain repetitive trends may be emerging. For the record, I haven't watched any Palace games bar the Match of the Day highlights and am in no position to comment on your team. What I am outlining below are a few factors that led to extremely poor performances under Alan Pardew at Newcastle United that were clear for all to see but patently ignored by the occasional commentators from the national perspective when a parting of ways occurred. They may or may not be starting to sound familiar:

There is no Plan B

In the multitude of (retrospectively ignored) terrible runs we endured under Pardew, the Groundhog Day effect of the games was crushingly frustrating. When the initial set up failed, the coaching staff were clueless and unwilling to adapt. Players continued to struggle out of position, those with shredded confidence remained in the team and pointless like-for-like substitutions on exactly 60 or 70 minutes had no effect. Often games were over by half time as the opposition helped themselves to a 3-0 lead and you wondered if you'd have been better off staying in the pub.

The Losing Culture Festers

I have seen players utterly destroyed at NUFC in recent years. Some of them have made an inglorious exit, some have gone on to prove themselves elsewhere and others..... Well, they're still there actually. There never seemed to be an intervention or an attempt to take responsibility from the management to raise confidence (which there should be in a tactical surrender). This would see the team sink lower and lower. Sometimes a pocket of form would be hit and see temporary respite, but inevitably the next defeat would launch another miserable run where your team walks onto the field looking beaten.

Your Maverick can save you

Palace fans may well remember a visit to St James' in March 2014 where you got absolutely mugged by an injury time smash and grab from one Papiss Demba Cisse (we lost our next six games mind). This was not an uncommon occurrence around this time, as Cisse saved our worthless hides on many an occasion. He is largely frustrating, injury-prone and struggles with the offside rule, but the matches he has salvaged points in over the past two years (often in desperate or last-ditch circumstances) has kept us slightly higher than 18th place. Cisse's inconsistent nature sometimes belied the destructive mood at the club, and he could produce goals unexpectedly. I wonder if Yannick Bolasie may be set to "do a Papiss".

No-one believes you

You don't need me to tell you the life of a mid/lower table team with unspectacular appeal. TV visits occasionally but largely to see you take on the 'big boys'. You tend to feature in the final third of Match of the Day. Generally, the national exposure is minimal for the club you see just about every minute of. However, you may find that passing comment based on this large-scale exposure is frowned upon. Instead you will be hit with a lazy statistic (our 2012 5th place = your 2015 highest ever PL finish) or reminded of your place in the football food chain i.e. Not Chelsea or Man Utd. The fact that your years of watching or being involved in football couple with the constant immersion in the topic in question may give you some credentials to speak is one that doth butter no parsnips.

This final point is, I believe, the source of much frustration amongst Newcastle supporters that Palace fans may have felt, directly or indirectly. We watched our club slowly erode from within only to be told we were ingrates or delusional pricks, regardless of the statistically supported and (chiefly) logically articulated arguments we put against the Pardew regime. We may well have formed the opinion that the success of 2012 was supported by the solid defence inherited from (well-liked) Chris Hughton, or that the Carver/Stone side that was overtaken by Palace last year was suffering from the continuation of Pardew's confidence suffocating culture and staffed by his appointees, but this counted for nothing. Journalists like Paddy Barclay and 'experts' like Ian Wright had seen a couple of games on Sky and remembered that we once drew 4-4 with Arsenal. As people who work in football, their opinion is better. We took a bit of stick, never more so than when we dutifully shipped 5 at Selhurst.

It is because of this reason that some have reacted with unsavoury glee to the recent slide at Palace. I don't think anyone wishes ill on your club as you are pretty much on a similar ride to the one we have experienced. Things going well for a while make you want to believe, then when you hit a blip its dismissed as temporary, something to work through. To validate this Alan's always there with a reason. As we started to underperform regularly in 2012/13 the Europa league copped for the blame, all these pesky Thursday nights in Russia and Belgium causing total devastation to the highly paid professionals asked to play again three days later. It seems that an injury crisis is being trotted out in the current Palace predicament (we had plenty of these as well, but oddly no statement is ever made regarding addressing the root causes).

The realisation is horrible when it dawns on you that the good season was the blip, like the twist at the end of a M. Night Shymalan film. Most in the north east, me included, remain convinced that when your bad run ends it will only be a matter of time before you are subjected to another. There are probably enough points on the board for you guys not to worry this season, but the future may hold more difficult times.

There was a period where we would have felt similarly affronted when these warnings were raised by the fans of West Ham, Southampton and Charlton. The main issue for me is that NUFC fans have been misrepresented as biased towards Londoners/Southerners, filled with unrealistic expectations and guilty of victimisation (trust me, we are well aware Mike Ashley is the main problem). The only problem we had was that Pardew had a management style that fostered a losing mentality, and by the time of his departure this was into a third season of lower table misery.

As I'm writing this on Monday I genuinely wish you very well in your next fixture and hope you come out the other side of all this. Don't worry, when you're trying to warn QPR fans in a couple of years, we'll back you up.

Jamie is a writer and reporter for Newcastle United magazine The Mag and is on Twitter at @Mr_Dolf

Crystal Palace 1-2 Watford: Emmanuel Adebayor scores but Pape Soaure sent off - 5 things we learned

Written by Robert Sutherland

It was another disappinting home defeat as Palace went down 2-1 to Watford at Selhurst Park.

The Eagles are now in the Premier League bottom three when it comes to home form as Troy Deeney's double inflicted their eighth home defeat of the season.

Emmanuel Adebayor had leveled Deeney's opener right on half-time before Watford scored again in the final 10 minutes. Pape Soaure compunded Palace's misery by getting sent off in injury time.

Here are 5 things we learned from the game.

1. Souare's red is opportunity for defence

Pape Souare's performances have been subject to criticism in recent weeks and it could be argued that the player should have been rested prior to this match. The red card he received for a two-footed tackle following a horror-throw from Wayne Hennessey means that Palace now face their next three fixtures without a specialist left-back. But perhaps that will offer some change that we need.

Souare's tendency to drift towards the goal often left his marker exposed, giving ample opportunity and time for a cross to come in. It happened at Swansea and in the preceding fixtures too. An enforced reshaping of our defence might not be such a bad idea.

2. Oh how we could do with Watford's clinical simplicity

Watford aren't an amazing side - a point that isn't meant to be a slight on who they are or what they do - they aren't a team which has, on the whole, cost a fortune to build.

But what they are is a side which knows it's strengths and weaknesses. It knows what it can and can't do. It doesn't go for shortcuts or the extravagant when it knows that simple and effective will do.

There were spells in the first half where Watford worked the midfield brilliantly. They bypassed Yohan Cabaye, Jordon Mutch and Mile Jedinak with such ease that they made it look like our three midfielders weren't even there.

And their winning goal - which came after a prolonged spell of pressure from Palace - was indicative of how they executed when it mattered most. They saw out our pressure and hit us at a point where we should, defensively, have done better.

Simple and precise football is what we need right now.

3. Palace are now struggling with the psychological impact of this run

The penalty we conceded after just ten minutes - for Mile Jedinak's blatant foul on Deeney as a Watford corner was drilled in - hit Palace massively. It came at a point where both sides were still finding their grooves, and it gave Watford a lead which they truly didn't deserve.

The concern for Alan Pardew and the fans will have been the way in which the players seemingly lost their heads in the 20-30 minutes that followed. Simple passes were ignored for long, hopeless punts to Emanuel Adebayor and Connor Wickham. Clearances which should have been made were clouded by doubt, allowing Watford to pounce. Extra touches were taken when quick, incisive passes would have sufficed.

Our players are all capable of better. We've seen them play better. We've seen them perform to much higher standards. But these spells in matches, where logic seems to take second stage, are concerning. We need our characters, our leaders, to stand up and lead by example.

4. A striker scored a goal from open play!

It may have taken Palace until February but one of their strikers actually scored a goal from open play. And it was Emmanuel Adebayor on just his second start for the Eagles who got it. And when it came it was a very well executed goal indeed.

The chipped cross from Wickham was inch perfect - probably the only decent cross Palace put into the box all afternoon - and the Togo striker met it with a perfect looping header. It was the only positive moment of the first half but it was worth waiting for.

That bit of quality suggests Wickham and Adebayor could have something resembling a relationship up front, if the former Sunderland man is played centrally and not out wide.

5. It could have been different but for a post

Much like at Swansea last week, in the second half Palace started to turn it on. Whatever Pardew said at half-time worked for the second week running as the response after the break was exactly what was needed. He needs to start saying whatever it was before games!

And the Eagles did have chances in the second half. Gomes in the Watford goal saved from Jordon Mutch and Adebayor while Yohan Cabaye saw an excellent volley smash the upright before Zaha blazed the rebound over. On another day one of those goes in and it's a different story.

It doesn't subtract from a disappointing display and result but the margins are perhaps a bit closer than we thought they were.

BONUS BALL!

It's since been pointed out to us on Twitter by Sebastian F that five of Palace's eight home defeats have come with goals in the final 10 minuntes.

Against Man City, West Ham, Sunderland, Tottenham and Watford the winning goals were scored once the clock had ticked past 80 minutes.

This is a worry that the team can't seem to hold out until the end. Under Tony Pulis that wouldn't have even been a question and certainly would not be a stat the team would be worrying about.

Is the team not fit enough or is it a concentration issue? Whatever it is it's cost Palace 10 points this season.


Brighton fan admits: Why REMF charity games means I don't hate Palace anymore

Written by Brett Mendoza

Brighton and Crystal Palace; the rivalry that miffs the rest of the footballing world. Growing up as a kid at The Goldstone through the late 80’s and early 90’s it was obvious to me that Palace were our rivals.

I didn’t know why? I just heard the chants, learned the words and “hated” Crystal Palace just like everyone who surrounded me. For me the problem was that I never saw us play them. I would ask friends and read articles, but never got a definitive answer. However, both sets of fans bought into it and the rivalry is there.

Fast forward to 26th October 2002, my first ever derby day match. I have never seen anything like it. Real angry men, shouting, chanting, luzzing any random objects at each other and of course a police presence like no other.

I guess 13 years since the last game must have brewed an awful lot of tension, but still I didn’t really understand it. A humiliating 5-0 defeat made me realise how much I hated like Palace. It was the worst experience at any football match I had been too.

In 2004, I played my way into The Robert Eaton Memorial Fund team, making a cameo appearance and scoring with my first touch on debut. Since then, I have played in nine REMF games, managing the team twice. In that time, the REMF matches have seen similar squads play each other throughout the years, so friendships started to build between the two sets of teams.

Having started my REMF career, as a favour for a friend, with the bonus of getting the chance to play on the hallowed turf of Withdean Stadium, I became so involved that it became a huge part of my life. (That's me up there celebrating last year's victory at Lewes FC)

I started fundraising as well as playing. Part of the fund raising efforts meant building up connections with the Palace end of things, and as a result, some great friendships were created.

It made me realise, that after all I was taught in my formative years as a Brighton fan, that the fact was I don’t really hate Palace. I openly say it on the social media network, which leads to some stick, and some people even questioning whether or not I am a true Brighton fan? For various reasons, there are teams I hate more than Palace; Manchester United, Chelsea and Portsmouth being those teams.

To me the rivalry is now more pantomime villain than arch enemy. I don’t really see the need for any violence or anger, but obviously it does happen. There is always banter between me and my Palace friends, especially as Palace are always above us and beating us. Thankfully the last game at The Amex changed that, we finally won with a glorious victory in the rain.

The good thing I can say about Palace fans on the whole is that you come across as local people supporting your local team. I can only applaud that, especially with big teams like Arsenal and Chelsea on your doorstep, oh and Spurs too.

This years REMF offers another great chance to show that the rivalry between the clubs doesn’t have to be a horrible one. In fact, it proves that working together we can do brilliant things. 

Join us at the Amex Stadium on Monday May 30th to see if Palace can win. Tickets are £5 for adults, U16s in free and kick-off is 6pm.

Andy Johnson and Robert Quinn will be playing for the Eagles!


Five Things We Learned: Swansea (06/02/2016)

Written by Robert Sutherland
1. The rot looked like it had really set in

Palace wavered listlessly from the kick-off today - and in the aftermath of Gilfy Sigurdsson's impressive free-kick - it looked like that rot we had all talked about had well and truly set in. That defensive resilience we were all so proud of prior to the crazy run of defeats had dissolved, leaving a side that was bereft of organisation and aimless in its approach. For 20 minutes, the Eagles toiled. More of the same for the rest of the match would doubtlessly have resulted in serious questions being asked about just how Palace could get out of that rut. But, with a tactical switch (the ineffective Jordon Mutch moved to the wing, taking an even worse Chung Yong-Lee's place) Palace suddenly found their feet and the half ended with some reasonable approach play. It's to Palace's credit (and Pardew's) that the side played with a much greater level of intensity, inventiveness and organisation. Mutch made a greater impression on the wing; Marouane Chamakh brought a little more composure to the side - and so the run of defeats came to an end. That rot that we're worried about needs a bit more treatment, though. A win soon should do it. 

2. Lee lacks defensive instinct
Pape Souare's positioning was questioned after the Bournemouth result in this feature - and there are still some concerns - but his frailties weren't helped by the completely ineffective performance from Lee. The South Korean international has many attributes which Palace could make use of - but defending is not one of them. Souare was exposed on multiple occasions, with Swansea doubling up against the left-back at every opportunity. On most of those occasions, Lee would stroll back, barely putting pressure on the full-back (his marker) as he ran past. The tactical switch which saw Mutch take Lee's place on the wing made an immediate impact to our defensive game - there were still some attacks down the left - but Mutch at least put the effort in to get himself in the way. The change also made a difference in an attacking sense, as Mutch made a greater use of the ball while in possession. 
 
3. Adebayor has class to make Palace shine
It was arguably a little too soon for Emanuel Adebayor to start today's match -- he's still a little rusty and lacks that match-fitness that you need in the Premier League. However, for all the lack of match action, he put in an excellent shift which saw him make a massive nuisance of himself throughout. For someone as gangly as he is, he certainly has a physical edge that defenders hate dealing with. After Palace's equaliser, there was also an excellent spell of play in which he, Mutch and Ward worked well together. It's also worth noting that he had a vision for passes that we've lacked - he put Wilfried Zaha clear on a couple of occasions with excellently timed, brilliantly-executed passes. By the time he went off, Adebayor had tired - but there's a lot to be pleased about. A few more games will see that talent shine. 
 
4. At such a critical time, it's easy to get sucked in
Negativity is poisonous. It feeds anxiety. Makes you angry with the slightest of errors. Makes you question the logic of those entrusted with making decisions. Makes you rant at the undeserving. At 1-0 down to Swansea (and when Palace went 2-1 down to Bournemouth, too) I found myself poisoned by that negativity. That anxiety that I was feeling was displayed on the pitch. You can sense it at the Liberty Stadium, and you could sense it on Tuesday as Palace lost to Bournemouth. I got sucked into that. I ranted at every defensive error. Groaned at every misplaced pass. Questioned the line-up, the goalkeeper, the left-back, the winger. It's so easy for that to get a grip of you; for you to get sucked into that void of frustration. Scott Dann's goal - for whatever reason - seemed to plug that void. It seemed to release some of that pressure - and you could feel it. In the crowd and the players. And in the manager, who - at the the full-time whistle - strode towards the away fans with clenched fists. 43 days without a point took their toll on all of us. 
 
5. Let the kids play
Hiram Boateng was Crystal Palace's first academy debutant in four years and 16 days (thanks to Matt Woosnam for that stat) when he played for the last 18 minutes of the match. The centre-mid could have had a remarkable debut with a run and shot that was deflected narrowly wide of the post - and for most of the 18 minutes, he did what was required of him. There will always be a lot of pressure on young players to succeed - we want to see our own players in the side. However, the best thing we can do as fans is not to be too analytical in our appraisal of their performances. There is a steep learning curve for most players who encounter the Premier League for the first time - more so for players who've played just a limited number of games below the Championship level. The only way Palace can really judge if a player is capable of making that jump is by giving them the springboard to do it. Boateng has the application - he wouldn't have been on the bench if he didn't have it - now he just needs more time. That might be out on loan, or it might be with fleeting performances for Palace. Either way, it was great to see him feature. 
 

Opinion: Things aren't actually that bad

Written by Jay Crame

Returning from South Wales with a point firmly in the hands of the Eagles felt like a win considering recent form.

The last point in the league came at home against the same opponents to see out what was a fantastic year for the club but few would have predicted how things would change.

The point is significant as Palace move off the 31 points they have been stuck on for almost six weeks. It remains to be seen if that point is the catalyst for a change in fortune but there is no doubting that it is a real shot in the arm to the players who have visibly struggled of late.

A mixture of lost form by certain players along with a growing injury list that has been a problem all season could well begin to ease a little as we head into a home fixture against Watford.

While the fortunes on the field of play have been tough for the players, their performances on social media have been strong. An image posted by Yohan Cabaye of the players on their trip back to Selhurst after the game at the Liberty Stadium says an awful lot about the good feeling among the squad. When Emmanuel Adebayor signed, all the players stood a free kick mannequin donned in Damien Delaney’s dodgy clothing choices with the quote ‘welcome to our new signing’.

Some fans may not like this kind of thing by the players, questioning why they should be allowed to have fun during such struggles in the league but I consider it an important part of team bonding and it is an awful lot to do with the way that we play, a real team ethic, playing for each other.

Hopefully some of that will return to the pitch again soon, and I believe that it will. The precious point gained away at Swansea stops the rot and will no doubt boost much needed confidence. There have been signs lately of a return to form, the loss against Spurs was disappointing but before they scored their second Palace really had a go at them and should have scored. The win over Stoke in the cup was another sign of things to come and at times against Bournemouth, Palace showed enough to beat them.

The introduction of Adebayor has been openly welcomed by the players and it looks like he has slotted in to life in South London well. There is a real hope that he will contribute with goals but his experience and wealth of know-how on the training ground could be priceless.

It has been the worst injury crisis that I can recall as a Palace fan. While you can perhaps compensate for one or two first choice players out, any more than that becomes tough to replace like for like in terms of quality. Many thought Palace had one of the best squads ever seen at the club going into this season but the absentees have been sorely missed.

Fact remains, the first choice eleven were soaring high in the top four earlier in the season and there is no reason why once those players are all back fit, form will return along with a welcome climb back up the table.

If I had known before the season started that Palace would be three points ahead of Chelsea at this stage and in with a chance of finishing in the top ten, I would have been very content. To the contrary, if I had been told at the same time that Palace would be 21 points behind Leicester I would have been very worried!

There is also the small matter of a second successive fifth round FA Cup appearance so while there has been a lot of doom and gloom banded around of late, it really is not that bad.

It could be a whole lot worse. Just take a peek at our South London neighbours ....


Palace Have Plateaued

Written by Alistair Laban

ChungyMuch of the reaction to the defeat by Bournemouth has been expectedly negative, with questions being raised about the clubs ambition, transfer policy and commitment on the pitch. This salvo of criticism has been countered by others who demand patience, don’t want to gamble on big money signings and are chuffed with the acquisition of Emanuel Adebayor. The fact of the matter is, we are experiencing a slump in form and are slipping down the table – but I don’t think that’s down to events over the last few weeks.

Firstly, we should give enormous credit to Bournemouth. They have come up with a primarily Championship squad, made some good signings and despite suffering a bizarre number of serious injuries, have stuck to their task and look like a good bet to avoid relegation.

They came to Selhurst with a proper game plan and it worked perfectly. I haven’t seen a team with such desire and dedication to their individual roles in a long while – they reminded me of how we were under Pulis when we achieved our own great escape. Eddie Howe did a great job in lining up his side to play up to the referee, upset (persistently foul) our players and get the crowd wound up. Despite not creating a great deal, they did what it took and ultimately, went home with the three points.

So what about Palace? We all offer our interpretation as to what the problem is and what could be done to get us winning again. My explanation is pretty simple really. The best place to start, and I think most would agree, is our key players. We desperately miss Yannick Bolasie’s willingness to drive at the opposition and take the game by the scruff of the neck, Connor Wickham’s ability to hold the ball up in the attacking third and due to the lack of a consistent and effective attack, Yohan Cabaye is struggling to work the magic expected of him.

We then look to the regular, solid, old faithful players – James McArthur, Wilfried Zaha, Joel Ward, Damien Delaney, and Scott Dann. Jason Puncheon is also in that list, but right now he shouldn't be.

He constantly turns his back on tackles, floats in 'safe' crosses and for the last few weeks (if not months) just isn't delivering any genuine attacking threat. Chung Yong Lee’s reward for a great performance against Stoke was a start against Bournemouth, and I thought he showed his international class on the wing(s). When Pardew brought on Marouane Chamakh to chase the game, he took Chungy off despite Puncheon contributing nothing to the game up to that point in his favoured position as a number 10.

That then leaves us with the fringe (or less reliable) players, which at present, we are heavily dependant on. For me, Souare’s positioning all over the place, Jordon Mutch doesn't offer a great deal, Chamakh can’t stay fit and even if Dwight Gayle were fit, Pardew probably wouldn’t play him. Then there’s Frazier Campbell.

Top six teams don't carry those players. Top eight teams might have to rely on one or two every so often. Top half teams would use a couple regularly. We are currently using at least four which in turn, leaves little impact to offer from the bench.

I don’t think there is a specific reason or reasons why we have taken a dip in form and are staring down the barrel of a 9th – 16th place finish. We have simply plateaued. As a squad, we have reached our level. Our current squad depth means we have to play players that aren't any better than our current league position and the players on the bench aren’t going to change games. Don’t get me wrong, I am not complaining or laying into the ability of our players; it just takes time to build a squad that is capable of challenging for higher positions. In this league, it could take a full season of development and effective signings to move up just one final league place. Obviously teams can be lucky/unlucky or go on good/bad runs and make good/bad signings that might give a slightly false impression of where they finish, but ‘the table doesn’t lie’ is adage for a reason.

So for perspective – we are not going down because we are better than majority of clubs in bottom half. Are we good enough for top 10? Yes. For the top six? No. For eight place? Well, that's where luck and injuries come in and is determined by squad depth and genuine quality. We have been in the top flight for just three years, so we might get lucky, we might not. If we want stability and progression we must have patience. If we want to rise from mid-table to European places in a season we need to be prepared to risk everything we have built over the last five years, and quite possibly lose it all. To justifiably challenge a European place, we are an order of magnitude off – that would take at least another two seasons of genuine, significant improvement. The problem is that I expect bloggers from Southampton, Stoke, West Ham, Everton and Liverpool would say the same.