Julian Speroni v Alex McCarthy v Wayne Hennessey: Who should be Palace's number one?

Written by Gary Byfield

Who should be between the sticks for Palace's opening game of the season at Norwich? by Gary Byfield tries to decide. 

 

Last season was of course a successful one with the team finishing top half and securing another campaign in the English Premier League, however it was not without its lessons learnt and one lesson that most will agree on was the need for someone to step between the posts once Julian Speroni's reign comes to an end. The recent CPFC preseason trip to South Africa came to host some what of a goalkeeping monage-a-trois with the expected, but strangely delayed, announcement of former QPR stopper Alex McCarthy joining the men in red and blue.

The arrival of McCarthy was not a surprise and had been on the cards for a while but he has joined an already strong line up. Competition was already high with SE25 legend and fans favourite Julian Speroni along with Welsh number one Wayne Hennessey battling it out last season.

With reports suggesting that former Palace boss, Tony Pulis, was interested in WH it seemed as though we would be down to 2 potential first choice keepers however the recent news that Speroni is out for 4-6 weeks it now seems to be between Hennessey and McCarthy as to who will take the number 1 albeit perhaps temporarily. 

 With rumours circulating that WH was due to move to WBA to join up with his former gaffer social media was awash with condemnation of letting him go. He has been given very little league game time and has mainly pulled on the Palace for the cup, during Speroni's injury and and at the end of the season to allow JS to stay fit for his testimonial.It was felt amongst fans that he wasn't given a fare crack and he was the perfect replacement as first choice and should actually start the season as number 1. 

When he has payed he has performed competently and consistently. Under Alan Pardew Palace have never lost with WH in goal with one of his notable performances against Southampton away in the FA Cup which Palace managed to squeeze out a 2-3 win. 

A lot like AM his strengths comes from his height, command and his very very long kick. In the modern game a good goal kick can immediately turn into an offensive move and put the opposition on the back foot which is something Palace have been missing from having JS in goal. 

Alex McCarthy joins us from QPR with very little game time since joining the club from Reading. He was kept out the side by Rob Green and he will be hoping the same does not happen at Palace. His stock was high when leaving Reading and even had offers from Liverpool but he ironically chose QPR to ensure first team action, needless to say that unfortunately did not happen.

His debut for Palace was questionable and came against Sporting Lisbon in the final of the preseason tour. Unfortunately for him the game ended 2-0 with the first goal coming from a free kick that couldn't be stopped by a weak hand, most will say he should have done better.

The performance was a shaky one and did not show a man at the peak of his confidence. This, I believe, can be put down to nerves and a lack of game time. His second start for the club was more positive and kept a clean sheet against Bromley before being subbed at the 70 minute mark. 

There is very little to choose between the 2 relatively new additions to the squad, however given the situation with Speroni and the performances during pre season I believe WH is the deserved number 1 choice leaving McCarthy to warm the bench. A lot like his time at QPR. However this does not mean that will happen and given AM left QPR to get first team football Pardew must have given him some reassurance that this would happen. 

Follow Gary on Twitter. 


 

What Crystal Palace can expect from Connor Wickham - a Sunderland fan's point of view

Written by Guest Blogger

Connor Wickham has joined Palace so we get the thoughts of Chris Thompson from the excellent Sunderland fanzine A Love Supreme, who seems a tad frustrated at the striker's lack of development in the North East.

The year is 2015.

Society has collapsed upon itself and Britons are enslaved by Greg Dyke and the Premier League. The UK is a bubble of engineered news, with Lad Bible the primary source for world affairs. Instead of communicating in lexicon, humans lift weights at each other and grunt, a communicative grunt. Government leaders aren't made in universities, they're made in Pure Gym. 

A footballer is not measured by his skill or accomplishments, but by the volume of his quiff and the amount of visible skin that he has left on his forearms. He has no time for training, only tweeting about training, the coverage much more rewarding than the actual act.

By far the most esteemed professional footballer is Connor Wickham. Wickham has surpassed Ryan Giggs' record of winning 12 Premier League titles by gaining over 31,000 followers on Instagram. Connor is also a pioneer in time management - having pre-cut vegetables delivered to his home each week has saved him literally minutes of his day. He has also slept with at least one member of the cast of ITV2's 'The Only Way Is Essex', which has not only increased his profile globally but also secured him an invite to the prestigious resort of Marbella. Wickham is, by all means, a visionary, a pioneer.

On the pitch though, Wickham lets his feet do the talking: netting a staggering 15 goals in 91 appearances. Wickham has a very independent, DIY approach to the game, often hanging onto the ball until he is tackled, even though the obvious pass would be far easier; Wickham never takes the easy option, which shows great character and mental strength. His ability to have a jumping height lower than his actual standing height is another impressive element to Connor's game.

Wickham is genetically superior to most men, having developed at a young age to surpass the strength and athletic ability of his peers. By the age of 19 though, Wickham decided to stop trying, he considered his physical advantage unfair and hence settled with his current ability to level the playing field. His lack of drive or motivation to better his ability as a professional footballer comes not from laziness, stupidity or having distorted priorities, but out of respect for his fellow tradesman. Perhaps the crown jewell of accomplishments though is that Wickham has established himself as the least popular striker in a Sunderland side that contains an overtly Newcastle supporting Danny Graham.

In his own mind, Wickham is the best player in the world, and his genuinely superior physical attributes - blistering pace, bison-like strength, sledgehammer shots - suggest that he probably could be, but he never will be. Call it lack of motivation or lack of footballing intelligence, all that can be agreed upon is that Wickham lacks something very important, whatever it may be.

Palace are getting an extremely gifted and talented player who could easily score 20 goals a season, but he won't, and that is a huge shame for all involved.

Follow Chris on Twitter


 

Have Crystal Palace stopped swaying from one disaster to the next?

Written by Neil Peters

With this wave of optimism, is disaster just around the corner; or have CPFC2010 finally broken the Palace mould, asks Neil Peters.

With promotion and back to back mid-table finishes in the last three seasons, Crystal Palace appear to be on an upward trajectory. The return of prodigal son Wilfried Zaha, the rise to prominence of bargain buys such as Yannick Bolasie and a proper manager, one of our own in Super Al, splashing the cash on proven international talent in Yohann Cabaye, optimism has never been higher. Ian Wright is saying that we’ll win a cup and Pardew quoted as saying that we can beat anyone outside the top 5.

So disaster is just around the corner, right?

Every Palace fan that has followed the club for more than 5 years know that every minor high is followed by a spectacular fall from grace.

The “Team of the 80s”, promoted in ‘79 was relegated in ’81.

The first Steve Coppell team of Wright, Bright and Thomas got promoted in ’89, got to the cup final, then won the Zenith Cup and finished 3rd in 1991. By 1993 the team packed full of England international was broken up and relegated. 

Even more recently Neil Warnock took Palace into the play-offs in 2008. By 2009-10 the club was plunged into administration. We sold star players Jose Fonte and Victor Moses to keep the coffers ticking over, deducted 10 points and the club survived a history ending relegation by the skin of its teeth.

Enter CPFC2010; the consortium lead by Steve Parish took the club out of administration and into a new era. There were problems, of course; but something had changed. Every time the club hit the buffers, instead of being derailed, they improved.

The first managerial appointment was George Burley but by Christmas we were flirting with relegation. Dougie Freedman was promoted to manager, kept the club up and the following season stabilised the league position.  Then in 2012-13 season, the team exploded out of the blocks, racing to the top of the league, things could not be better. But inexplicably in October, club hero Freedman walked out on the club where he was loved to join Bolton Wanderers.

The next 4 managerial appointments follow a similar pattern:

Holloway took the club up and then seemed to have a complete meltdown and resigned a year to the day after Freedman left, leaving the club rock bottom of the Premier League.

Pulis, a Premier League miracle worker defied all belief and took the team from 20th to 11th in 6 months.

We thought we’d found our long term manager at last, but Pulis walked out in spectacular style on the eve of 2014/15 season. This should have derailed the club, but Neil Warnock came in as a steadying hand before Alan Pardew took over the reins and lead the club to our highest league position for the best part of a quarter of a century.

So what next for Palace? I don’t think we’ve had 3 good seasons in a row since I’ve supported them, let alone 4. My instinct is that disaster will strike, Pardew will walk out, Bolasie will be sold to Spurs and Cabaye will be an injury prone flop.

But maybe, just maybe, Mr Parish and Co, having asked Palace fans to stop thinking like Palace fans may have hit on a winning formula.

Follow Neil on Twitter. 


 

What to expect from Patrick Bamford - a Middlesbrough fan's point of view

Written by Guest Blogger

Can the England U21 striker do the business for Palace? Boro blogger and freelance writer Tom Etherington explains what we're in for.

 

There were mixed feelings across Teesside last week as Boro’s hopes of signing Patrick Bamford for another season were ended by Crystal Palace.

It was always going to be a longshot, after the highly-rated striker set the Championship alight and deservedly picked up the Player of the Year Award, but the fans and club still held out some hope.

Bamford scored 17 goals in 32 appearances en route to the Play-Off final, and even though Boro fell at the final hurdle, it was already apparent that the 21-year-old was ready to play Premier League football next season.

Despite the disappointment, I’m confident most of those associated with Boro will agree that Crystal Palace is the right step for Bamford’s progression, following previous spells in League One with MK Dons and Derby County in the Championship. But what can the Eagles expect from him in the Premier League? 

Following his drawn-out arrival from Chelsea in August, Bamford didn’t actually get off to the best of starts at the Riverside, regularly being named on the bench and going three games without a goal. The England youngster quickly became frustrated and actually had words with boss Aitor Karanka about the squad rotation policy, which led to him being handed his first start at home to Brentford.

The opportunity proved to be fruitful as Bamford netted in an emphatic 4-0 win and went on to grab a last-minute equaliser against Liverpool in the Capital One Cup just a few days later.

One of Bamford’s biggest problems though is inconsistency. Following the heroics at Anfield, he went five games without finding the net, then scored six goals in seven to help Boro remain unbeaten in November and December, before leaving it another 6 games to score again.

It was this sort of form that left some fans unconvinced, but Bamford’s saving grace was being able to score when it really mattered. He popped up with four crucial equalisers and opened the scoring in nine Boro wins throughout the season, against Rotherham, Norwich, Cardiff, Manchester City, Charlton, Millwall, Wigan and twice against his former club Derby.

Alan Pardew will need to learn when he can get the best out of Bamford, whether that is part of his starting eleven or a second-half substitute, but that will come as the season progresses. His first concern should be where to actually play Bamford on the pitch. The forward regularly played out of his natural position under Karanka, starting on the right of a front three 14 times and on the left five times, which makes his goal scoring record even more impressive. But there is no doubt that Bamford is suited to the central role, and with Glenn Murray, Dwight Gayle and Fraizer Campbell to contend with at Selhurst Park, he may need to make the most of his versatility.

It will also be interesting to see how Bamford handles the physicality of the Premier League as he can be a little lightweight at times and struggled with a persistent ankle injury during the final few games of last season, including the Play-Off Semi-finals and Final.

To be fair to him though, Bamford played through the pain and still managed to give 100%. And when he is at full capacity, there are very few strikers with vision, pace, composure and finishing that could match his.

Boro are desperately searching for a striker of similar calibre to Bamford ahead of next season, with Jordan Rhodes the likely replacement, but I know for certain that the Chelsea loanee will be missed both on and off the pitch next season. Good luck to both Patrick and Palace.

Follow Tom on Twitter.


 

Where does Jason Puncheon fit in now Palace have signed Yohan Cabaye?

Written by Michael Brockman

Should Palace make room for Punch or will his position be in direct competition with Cabaye? How will Cabaye fit into the squad? Michael Brockman tries to work it out.

In an incredibly successful 2014/15 season for Palace, Jason Puncheon stood out as a player who made the difference in many matches. Whether it was his threat from set pieces, his licence to shoot from distance, or his fantastic close control in offensive areas, 'Punch' was arguably the most technically gifted player in the squad, and would regularly be the focal point of our attacking play.

Under the guidance of Alan Pardew, Puncheon moved from the wing and became a free spirit in the centre of the park. Being able to provide the link from midfield to attack, feeding Yannick Bolasie and Wilfried Zaha with his decisive passing, Puncheon allowed us to become an incredibly threatening team on the counter attack. He was also a huge threat from both indirect and direct free kicks- just ask David de Gea and Joe Hart! The qualities Puncheon brought to the team last season were vital in our success, which is why he will surely be one of the first names on the team sheet for the 2015/16 season.

With the arrival of Yohan Cabaye this summer, speculation has been rife over where the French international will play in the midfield. After watching some of our pre-season games, it appears that Pardew could be considering Cabaye in Puncheon's role from last season- just behind the striker. With the impossible notion of leaving a player of the calibre of club record signing Cabaye out of the starting XI, could this mean Puncheon's position is now under threat? Or does Pardew envisage a different game plan to keep both players in the team? Below are three different ideas which could make the latter option possible.

Firstly, playing Cabaye in the hole and Puncheon on the wing. While this could arguably limit Puncheon's creativity, let's not forget he did play this role to great effect while Bolasie was away at AFCON. This may mean a place on the bench for Zaha, who has proven to be an effective impact substitute in the past.

Secondly, playing Cabaye deeper- as he does on the international scene- with Puncheon in front of him in the attacking midfielder role. This really could bring out the best in both players, and certainly shows a quality core running through the middle of our XI.

Or thirdly, the two could be used as central midfielders with a licence to roam- along with the more physical Mile Jedinak playing just behind them shielding the defence- a (slightly) poor man's Xavi and Iniesta if you will. 

With the obvious versatility of both players, it does seem as if we can implement different game plans depending on the opposition we are facing- so I don't necessarily think that Puncheon and Cabaye will have set roles in the team. One thing is for sure though- the thought of having these two technically gifted footballers in the same starting XI will bring music to all Palace fans' ears, and will provide a lot of excitement in the build up to the season.

Follow Michael on Twitter


 

What can Crystal Palace expect from Alex McCarthy?

Written by Dan Wimbush

With Palace having announced the signing of QPR goalkeeper Alex McCarthy, Dan Wimbush from the Tilehurst End blog gives us the lowdown on the 25-year-old, who spent a significant time with Reading before moving to London.
Alex McCarthy
It's pretty safe to say that Crystal Palace will be getting a relative bargain if they do manage to pick up Alex McCarthy for just £3.5m. 

What's good for Palace will come as a big blow for Reading's bean counters who had no doubt expected the former England U21 keeper to net them a tidy sell-on fee after joining QPR for around £3m less than a year ago.

A dire financial situation at the Madejski Stadium coupled with the fact that Alex had just a year left on his deal meant that he had to be sacrificed as a saleable asset, leaving Adam Federici to run down his final year unopposed between the sticks.

While the move was understandable, few fans were happy to see the keeper leave the club as he was almost universally rated the better prospect in the long-term. Plus as an Academy graduate, Alex had an extra connection to the Reading fanbase that the Aussie didn't enjoy.

Even before making his Royals debut, McCarthy had already proved himself a highly promising goalkeeper out on loan. Yeovil and Brentford fans had only positive things to say about the keeper, who even took League Two's 'Golden Gloves' award while at Griffin Park.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mGhAP5UmOY

Once Marcus Hahnemann left Reading in 2009, McCarthy soon become the club's regular number two and when Federici suffered an injury during early 2011, Alex seamlessly took his spot, helping us not only to a play-off final but also to an FA Cup quarter-final where he put in an outstanding display against Manchester City.

Federici would take his spot back as the senior keeper but after a wobble during our return to the Premier League, McCarthy would again get the chance to impress. Excellent performances followed but an injury in the final minute of another brilliant display away at QPR saw him ruled out for four months just as he was poised to earn an England call-up.

Fortunately McCarthy returned none the worse from a shoulder injury and cemented his reputation as one of England's best young keepers with a remarkable performance against a Liverpool team containing Luis Suarez.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sc0i4o8GPo8

An England call-up followed for a friendly with Brazil but his return to the Championship with Reading dented his international chances before a year on the bench at QPR similarly kept him in the international shade.

So what are you getting from McCarthy?

His main strength is his shot stopping ability. If you watch either of the clips above then that becomes apparent, while his handling and command of his box are also plus points on his CV.

On the other hand his distribution has always been his major weak point, while some have questioned his ability to organise a defence effectively.

Palace are certainly 'buying low' on McCarthy. He's nowhere near his peak and if he gets a regular run of games could certainly force his way back into the England squad. He may never be a top, top goalkeeper but he's easily got the potential to at least be at the level of a Ben Foster or Fraser Forster.

All the best for the season, now if you could just send us Glenn Murray back...