Crystal Palace's In and Out List for the Transfer Window

Written by Robert Sutherland
With the transfer window opening at midnight, Crystal Palace will join a throng of other Premier League clubs looking to make improvements to the squad. So what should Palace focus on in the coming weeks? 
 
Here's Robert with a priority list. 
 
HF flag
 
IN:

Striker:

 

Embed from Getty Images

The most obvious addition to the squad, really. Palace need a forward who can be thrown in at the deep end. 
 
Where the club failed last year was that they brought in Alexander Sørloth with the hope he'd get up to speed during the remainder of the season. That didn't happen and the Norwegian international is in desperate need of a spell away from the club to acclimatise to English football. 
 
All the media reports indicate that that player will be Dominic Solanke -- a striker that hasn't featured regularly for Liverpool but whose reputation is stellar. Palace might just be able to offer him the chance to prove himself, in a similar vain to Ruben Loftus-Cheek. Let's hope Palace agreed a clause to sign him on a permanent basis in the summer.
 
Another player Palace are being linked with is Tammy Abraham, who Chelsea might recall from a successful loan spell at Aston Villa. Abraham has had a tough time in the Premier League with Swansea but his performances in the Championship suggest he perhaps deserves another crack at the division.  
 
The outsider's pick might be Jermain Defoe, who Palace have been frequently linked with in the past. The former Sunderland and Tottenham striker has struggled to get into the side at Bournemouth.
 

Winger:

Embed from Getty Images

 
With just Wilfried Zaha and Andros Townsend to call upon as wingers, Palace arguably need a little more depth in that area. While Roy Hodgson has played both Max Meyer and James McArthur in wide positions (albeit with instruction to play more narrowly) a little more depth would go a long way.  
 
Palace have been linked with Chelsea's Victor Moses, who hasn't featured much under Maurizio Sarri, and the former Palace youth player would make a very welcome return to Selhurst Park. Moses's added value is that he's capable of playing in either an advanced or defensive role. 
 
new player

Midfielder:

Another lesson Palace have learned from this season so far is that there can never be enough strength in depth. Roy Hodgson's persistence in selecting Jeffrey Schlupp in a midfield role is an indicator of how the club could perhaps do with another midfielder to call upon. 
 
Schlupp is a capable utility player, although having a specific role in the team might be more advantageous to both him and the club. It's clear that, at times, Schlupp struggles with knowing what his responsibilities are -- against Chelsea there were a number of occasions where he was caught out of position.
 
With finances being another hindering issue for the club this January, the likelihood of signing a midfielder is limited. A loan move for a player from abroad would be necessary given that, unless Jordan Ayew is returned to Swansea, the club wouldn't be able to make any more domestic moves with the arrival of Solanke. 
 

OUT: 
Sorloth miss

Alexander Sørloth:
The Norwegian striker was signed on the basis of his potential, but limited appearances and somewhat lacklustre performances in those appearances have meant that a loan move is the most likely way for Sørloth to gain experience. 
 
The striker has been linked with moves abroad, with Belgian club Gent mooted recently, although Palace would arguably prefer him to move to a club in England. 
 
Jairo
 
Jairo Riedewald: Signed by Frank de Boer from Ajax, the midfielder was supposed to be another player to develop in the side. Riedewald barely featured during De Boer's brief spell in charge, and despite making sporadic appearances for Hodgson, didn't do enough to establish himself in the side. 
 
The Dutchman was being linked with a summer move to Swansea in exchange for Jordan Ayew, but he refused to make the switch in the latter stages of the window. Having featured in just cup games this season, it seems clear that a move away from the club would do both hima and Palace some good. 
 
Embed from Getty Images
 
Jordon Mutch: A loan spell with the Vancouver Whitecaps in the MLS didn't materialise into a permanent transfer for the midfielder, and it's highly unlikely that he'll force himself back into the side at Palace again. A move to Cardiff has been hinted at. 
 
 Joniesta

Jonny Williams:
There's a point in a player's career where a move away from their home club makes sense. This is the time for Williams. The midfielder, who has been the victim of successive injuries, needs to play regularly. A move abroad might suit him best. 
 
Ayew control
 
Jordan Ayew: When Palace signed the winger, it was a move that looked sensible. The Ghana international had been Swansea's Player of the Season and was a decent goal threat for the Welsh club. But his move to Palace hasn't worked -- whether it's because he's being played as a striker, or because of a lack of intent when he does play, his performances have been underwhelming. 
 
If Palace can break the loan agreement during this window, it would be a sensible decision to make. 

Palace Ponderings: Chelsea Defeat Leaves All Frustrated

Written by Robert Sutherland

Sunday's defeat to Chelsea was deflating. Here's Robert Sutherland with some thoughts. 

WanBissaka1


Defensive Tactics Aren't the Problem

There was a fair bit of angst in the aftermath of Sunday's game against Chelsea, much of it focused on the defensive nature of Palace's performance.
 
Palace played with an approach that sought to limit Chelsea's attacking threat as much as possible, and (bar a couple of favourable offside calls) for much of the first half and plenty of the second, that worked. 
 
There is no shame in a side like this Palace team trying to stifle a side with the creativity that Chelsea possess. Even at home. It's what plenty of teams would have done in similar circumstances. 
 
The tactics Palace used weren't problematic. The performance and the the result were. A draw might have been called a good result. A defeat is deflating. 
 
Townsend stare


A Limited Squad makes for a Tired Team

We all know that while this is one of the best first 11 to have played for Crystal Palace, it's also clear that in terms of squad depth it lacks the back-up to fight through busy spells like this one. 
 
That showed against Chelsea, especially by the time the second half started. Palace were chasing shadows. 
 
It should be concerning to the club's management that the only reasonable change Roy Hodgson could make was to take a tired Max Meyer out of the side and replace him with Jeffrey Schlupp. There should be more options. 
 
As it is, the rest of the bench offers limited options. Scott Dann has only just returned from injury and looked quite rusty in the most recent U23 game. Connor Wickham is making a gradual return to the side. Joel Ward is an option but Aaron Wan-Bissaka seems to have ceaseless energy reserves. 
 
Perhaps Jason Puncheon should have had a run-out by now, but it seems that Hodgson doesn't trust the former club captain. 
 
The need for a striker is clear but Palace could do with another midfield option to call upon in times like these. Chelsea can rotate players in and out of the team, and that shows. 
 
 
Wickham cardiff


Palace need to Strike While the Iron's Hot

We're growing tired of the striker issue. This season, we've discovered that Wilfried Zaha isn't a striker. Jordan Ayew isn't a striker. Andros Townsend can strike the ball, but he's not a striker. Alexander Sorloth was supposed to be a striker, but we're not really sure he's capable at this level. Connor Wickham is a striker who has been out of action for two years so needs to be reintroduced gradually. It's time Palace signed another one to give the club hope of scoring some goals. 
 
Word is that Dominic Solanke is the player Palace have put their bets on to help the club score goals. The former Chelsea youth player has an extremely good reputation in the game. Chelsea were disappointed to lose him, while Liverpool worked hard to secure him. 
 
He's a player that should have had more Premier League games by now, and had it not been for the failed Liverpool move, that might have materialised. If he has anywhere near the impact that Ruben Loftus-Cheek had, it'll be a good move. 
 
Hopefully Palace can secure him by the start of the window, rather than allow it to drag on until the end of it. The need for a striker is that pressing. 
 
Zaha miss cardiff home


2018 Wasn't Wonderful, 2019 Will be About Tough Decisions

We all want Palace to have a season without stress. Without the fear of relegation. A few wins, a few defeats, a few draws and a nice and secure 9th place finish with a few weeks of fixtures towards the end of the season where there aren't any concerns. 
 
2018 was not the year where that happened or where the foundations were set for that to happen. This Palace side, as it currently stands, is going to be fighting to avoid the relegation crowd. That's not being negative, it's a realistic look at the current scenario. A squad that doesn't have a first-team capable striker for such a prolonged spell, where the manager is forced to experiment, is going to struggle to make chances count, score goals and win games. 
 
2019 will be the year where the ownership of the club will have to make some tough choices about whether a balanced squad is better than one with two or three star players and a lesser squad built around it. 
 
It is likely to be the year where we see some sad but necessary departures. 
 
Let's hope the club does it the right way. 
 
Happy New Year! 

What a Loan of Rubbish - A Look Back at Palace's Recent Premier League Loan Moves

Written by Skippy Windsor

Puncheon

With Dominic Solanke set to make the loan move to Palace and provide much needed reinforcement to a misfiring front line, Skippy Windsor looks back at the previous loans since Palace’s return to the Premier League.


Season 13/14

Embed from Getty Images

Cameron Jerome – Signed by Ian Holloway from Stoke, Jerome failed to make an immediate impact as a strike force of Gayle and Chamakh was preferred. However, his assist in Palace’s first away win at Hull under Keith Millen showed fans his strength and pace and with the arrival of Tony Pulis, Jerome become a constant fixture in the starting XI. Despite only scoring two goals, his work rate and ability to occupy defenders earned him respect amongst the Palace faithful. Verdict – Hit.

Puncheon celebate Norwich

Jason Puncheon – Holloway’s other loan signing arrived from South London, already well known to Palace fans for his exploits for Millwall. After struggling to nail down a starting place under Holloway, Puncheon was another beneficiary of the arrival of Pulis, flourishing on the right win and scoring important goals as Palace chased survival. His loan spell was cut short, to the benefit of Palace who were able to secure his permanent signature, allowing Puncheon to become one of the most important players in recent history. Verdict – Hit.

Embed from Getty Images

Tom Ince – Ince arrived in the January transfer window after apparent interest from European Giants, costing FYP thousands in £50 donations, as one of the highest rated youngsters in English football. His impact was immediate, scoring on debut against West Brom and embracing Pete the Eagle in celebration. However that was to be the last of his real contribution in a Palace shirt, as the wing combination of Puncheon and Bolasie become a Pulis favourite and Ince was limited to only eight appearances. Verdict – Miss.


Season 14/15

Embed from Getty Images


Kevin Doyle
– In one of the stranger moves in Premier League, Neil Warnock allowed Glenn Murray to go out on loan and brought in Kevin Doyle on loan from Championship Wolves. Doyle made three substitute appearances in the league, failing to score in any of them. His last appearance was in the FA Cup in Pardew’s first game as manager, as he ended his illustrious time at Palace with a goal against non-league Dover. Verdict - Miss

Wilf with ball

Wilfried Zaha – Having failed to make an impact after leaving the club, Zaha returned on loan from Manchester United, marking his comeback with a last minute equaliser away to Newcastle. Despite failing to be a regular fixture under Warnock, he flourished in the second half of the season under Pardew. Palace made his signature permanent once more, with Wilf going on to be one of the best players ever to adorn the Red and Blue, winning multiple Player of the Year awards since his return. Verdict – Hit.

Embed from Getty Images

Yaya Sanogo – French Striker Sanogo arrived from Arsenal in the January window following the appointment of Pardew, along with Ameobi, Chung-Yong Lee and Mutch to name a few (What a window that was!) A tall, gangly striker who lacked real Premier League quality, his only goal came away to Southampton in the FA Cup with Murray, Gayle and Chamakh viewed as better options to lead the line. Arguably his greatest contribution was inspiration to one of JD’s football songs! Verdict – Miss.


Season 15/16

Embed from Getty Images


Patrick Bamford –
Highly rated striker Bamford arrived after scoring 19 goals for Middlesbrough the year before, in a window that saw the departure of Glenn Murray and Dwight Gayle. Despite an impressive pre-season, Bamford is best remembered for spending more time fixing his hair than making a meaningful contribution on the pitch. He opted to terminate the loan himself, citing a lack of first-team chances, and no one in Selhurst was too upset at the decision having failed to score a single goal in his loan spell. Verdict – Miss.


Season 16/17

Embed from Getty Images


Loic Remy
– Remy joined on loan and on paper, looked to form a deadly partnership with the newly arrived Christian Benteke. However, straight after arriving, he suffered a knee injury and wasn’t to be seen until the 3rd round of the FA Cup, where he made his debut in a 0-0 draw at Bolton. Failure to remain fit, an alleged clash with Allardyce and Benteke hitting late season form meant that Remy was limited to a handful of minutes, failing to make any positive impact at all on Palace’s quest for survival. Verdict – Miss.

Embed from Getty Images


Mamadou Sakho –
Signed on loan from Liverpool on deadline day in the January Window, Sakho took a few weeks to get up to match fitness after hardly featuring for his parent club. He made his debut in the home win vs fellow strugglers Middlesbrough and formed a defensive partnership with James Tomkins that saw Palace claw themselves away from the relegation zone. He brought about calmness and talent the backline clearly lacked, notably starring in the away win against Chelsea. His performances earned him great respect from the Palace faithful and led to a permanent summer move the window after. Verdict – Hit.


Season 17/18

Embed from Getty Images


Erdal Rakip-
Who?

Embed from Getty Images


Timothy Fosu-Mensah –
Signed by De Boer as the right sided CB for his three at the back system, Fosu-Mensah covered multiple defensive injury crisis by playing both RB and CB for the Eagles. Pacey, if somewhat naïve, Fosu-Mensah had his best game matching up against Leroy Sane and nullifying arguably the most potent attack in the league. The emergence of Aaron Wan-Bissaka limited Fosu-Mensah in the back end of the season, but his loan spell was arguably mutually beneficial for both parties. Verdict - Hit

RLC Clap 

Ruben Loftus-Cheek – Highly rated midfielder Loftus-Cheek joined from Chelsea, providing both finesse and power in midfield. Operating centrally and as a wide-midfielder under Hodgson, Loftus-Cheek brought about class and talent to a team that struggled early on in the season. Capable of scoring vital goals, including in the home wins vs Leicester and Stoke, Loftus-Cheek’s performance at Palace earned him international recognition and a well-deserved World Cup call-up, in which he continued to shine on the biggest stage. Verdict - Hit


Season 18/19

 Ayew dejected

Jordan Ayew – Signed from Swansea and capable of covering either a wing or striking position, Ayew was brought in to provide cover and competition. With injury to Benteke, he has been asked to play centrally for much of his spell, with limited impact so far. It remains to be seen whether he will see out his loan spell and whether his fortunes can change in the Red and Blue.

Palace Ponderings: Townsend Screamer Helps Palace to Shock win At Manchester City

Written by Robert Sutherland

It's hard to believe that Crystal Palace won against one of the best sides ever to play in the Premier League, but they did just that. Here are Robert Sutherland's Palace Ponderings about the win...

Townsned thumbs up

Sweet Dreams are Made Of This

Wins over this Manchester City side don't fall into the realms of reality often. You hope and pray, but then you remember the 18 goals conceded since promotion, with none scored, and you dismiss both of those things and accept your fate. A trip to the Etihad is a trip to the depths of despair, as Pep Guardiola's side tear you apart and all you can do is watch.
 
It's like a scene from a David Attenborough documentary, where you know the gazelle is going to get caught by the lion but you just will that gazelle to find that little burst of pace to escape. The gazelle doesn't. But Crystal Palace did. Palace didn't just escape from the grasps of Manchester City's claws, they defeated the lion.
 
Gazelles dream of moments like these. 

A Premier Goal to Remember

Andros Townsend's goal will be the memory-maker. Everything that you recall from the City win will be tied to that goal. A split-second of utter insanity. 
 
When you see a goal like that, there's a moment where time becomes suspended. A silence falls as the ball careers from Townsend's foot and thunders into the back of Ederson's net. A blissful void of nothingness is pierced by the reality. It was a goal. A colourful, beautiful moment of realisation.
 
And it happened for fans of City, too. You could hear that reality strike as they collectively gasped 'oh' when the net bulged. It was a fantasy goal made reality. A dream come true.  
 
LISTEN: FYP Podcast EXTRAAA - We #FreeThePod after Christmas comes early at Man City
 

Townsend stare

On the subject of Andros Towsend...

No positive discussion about Townsend's contribution can ever be had without someone muttering the words 'yeah, but his end product...' -- both go hand in hand. But if all we do is look at Townsend's goal tally, you completely ignore the other elements of his game.
 
While Townsend's fantastic screamer was the highlight of the win, it was his all-round performance which deserves all the credit. Palace wouldn't have won had Townsend not covered as much ground as he did. Aaron Wan-Bissaka wouldn't have had as good a game without Townsend playing in front of him. Jeffrey Schlupp's goal wouldn't have happened had it not been for Townsend's initial touch, and his pivotal move in the centre of the field a few seconds later which fed the ball to James McArthur. These are small, insignificant moments that in sum made his a man of the match performance. 
 
Townsend is proof that you don't have to score goals to make a difference. It definitely helps; his goal was after all the one that gave Palace the lead (and the one we'll be talking about for a lifetime), but it was everything else he did that ultimately put Palace in a place where they could win. And he does that on a regular basis with little credit. 
 
 
Roy wet clap 

Roy's Tactical changes are Detailed, not Drastic

So much is said about Roy Hodgson's tactics, especially in defeat. His reliance on a 4-4-2 formation is often maligned. His lack of substitutes is criticised. His unwillingness to pick certain players is questioned. But beneath it all, there is a manager with ceaseless willpower and a defiance to persist, this in light of having a subs bench that really lacks quality. And that deserves praise. 
 
Palace wouldn't have won at Manchester City had it not been for the way the team were drilled. They wouldn't have done it had they not been as focused as they were. This is a Manchester City side that, in the second half, changed it's entire attacking line-up to try and break down a defence they'd struggled to defeat in the first half, only to encounter more of the same. A fluke goal from Kevin de Bruyne made the scoreline look a lot more flattering than it should have, as City had toiled for so long. 
 
Often, much of what Hodgson does is in the detail. The formation doesn't always change but the way the players work within that structure does. It was clear yesterday that the squad were happy to let City's defenders have the ball. The time to strike, for Palace's midfield and defence, was when the ball crossed the halfway line. The more City pushed forward, the more Palace's midfield compressed. It's like the Leicester City game to some extent -- Leicester had all the pace but Palace refused to be stretched to give them it. The same was applied to City -- they had all the space in their own half, but once they got near Palace's goal, the area where they are at their most threatening -- with short, sharp, incisive passing -- became a minefield of tackles and physicality.  
 
Not enough will be made of the tactics Hodgson instructed his team to play with. But that win was a credit to him and his coaching staff. 
 
 

Defeats Don't Have to Mean there's a Disconnect

There has been a lot of talk about the club, the players and the fans losing touch. About supporters losing that connection. Defeats do that, and this season has seen a few. 
 
The frustration of seeing your team lose, very often in scenarios where there are tight margins at play, is disheartening. But this is the team we know and love. This is why we're Palace fans. Disappointing defeats are part of the package. They make the sensation of winning against sides like City all the more delightful. And if you're a Palace fan, you can't have one without the other. 
 
Football clubs go through these fluctuations, and Palace are no different. We have to sometimes learn to take upsets like the Brighton defeat on the chin, because we know that there's always a chance that Palace can pull off the miraculous, as they did this weekend. It's the game we love, and the club we adore. 

Palace Ponderings - Frustration Lingers but Points are Points after Cardiff Stalemate

Written by Robert Sutherland

Palace did everything but score against Cardiff City. Here are Robert Sutherland's ponderings.

Wilf has Gone Off the Boil a Little, Let him get Hot and Bothered

Matches like Wednesday's draw against Cardiff City can bring frustrations to the boil. To see so many opportunities come and go, to have those chances go untaken, is frustrating. And no one showed that frustration more than Wilfried Zaha. 
 
Zaha reminds me of an old-school kettle whistling on the stove top, just as it reaches boiling point -- you can see the frustration and you can see from his actions that he's annoyed -- but like a kettle, good things come to those who wait. You need to leave that kettle there just a little bit longer to really make sure the water is hot enough. 
 
He is that kettle. He's whistling. He's hot and bothered. He's ready to spill over. But you know that, if you let him channel that frustration, or let the water boil a little longer, it'll be perfect when you serve it. 
 
Magic happens when Zaha is at his angriest sometimes. He needs that to drive him. Let that frustration get to him, allow him to have those moments of outbursts. The reward will be what he serves up. 
 

Guaita Offers a Firm Helping Hand

As a preface, this isn't about Wayne Hennessey. Not everything has to be looked at in a prism of comparison between the two goalkeepers. 
 
Vicente Guaita has won Palace points with his contribution since he came into the side. His save against Leicester City, which rebounded off the post, was remarkably quick and crucial. He showed excellent dexterity against Manchester City early in the game, and was ultimately unfortunate to concede from Kevin de Bruyne's effort. And on Wednesday, he made a remarkable, strong-wristed save from a shot by Kadeem Harris. 
 
Football is about opportunities you take, whether you're talking about actually playing or what you do in a match. Guaita, like Aaron Wan-Bissaka did last season, is taking the opportunity given to him and making the most of it. He's making Roy Hodgon's job more difficult. 
 
More saves and more winning performances should see him really cement his place in the side. The good news for Palace fans is that the goalkeeping position isn't a problem one. 

Wickham Wonderers See the Road to Recvoery is Long

It's been a long, arduous and often frustrating road to recovery for Connor Wickham. Almost two years since he first picked up the cruciate ligament injury, the striker returned to Premier League action with a performance that was as promising as it was revealing. 
 
Injuries like the one suffered by Wickham, and the subsequent setbacks he had, have undoubtedly impacted on his sharpness. So while the quickness of thought is there, the speed with which is body reacts isn't quite yet. 
 
Sporting professionals have to be carefully reintroduced to action. Wickham's body is his money-maker; the club have to respect the need to ensure he gets up to speed in a way which doesn't put him at further risk. So while the necessity was there for him to play because of the club's need for a goalscoring threat, that lack of sharpess underlined just how important a gradual reintroduction is. 
 
A few more sub appearances should see him ready to compete for a starting place. And that'll be a good thing for the club and the striker. 

Momentum is Key During Busy Christmas Period

The draw with Cardiff City on Boxing Day was entertaining. It was a good performance; the only thing missing from it was the finishing touch. Whereas almost every chance vs Manchester City went in, none of the chances Palace had vs Cardiff did. 
 
What is crucial for Palace though is the importance of carrying momentum. Wins and draws do that. One thing Tony Pulis made a point about, which is worth taking on board, is that when you start collecting points, you have to do everything you can to keep doing that. And while Palace could have thrown even more forward, the risk of conceding on the break was all too stark. 
 
It's better to exert the effort Palace did and accept that a draw was a good result, than to risk everything and lose. And with Chelsea next, the players will have everything focused on the visit from our West London neighbours. 
 

Palace Ponderings - No Wilf No Worries Against Leicester

Written by FYP Fanzine

It finally happened. Palace won without Wilf Zaha for the first time in over two years as they beat Leicester 1-0 at Selhurst. We learned some things while freezing our proverbials off. Here they are.

No Wilf, No Worries

Well, that's one very unwanted streak gone. Palace finally won a game without Wilf Zaha in the team, the first time since September 2016 and a 3-2 win at Sunderland. Game after game Roy Hodgson and his team (and fans) were reminded that when Wilf doesn't play Palace don't win and it's hard to ignore the psychological effect that had on the team (and the stands).

So to finally break the duck in a must-win game is huge really. We still do rely on Zaha far too much to create things going forward and that's a debate for another day but winning without him in the team, something that should really be a formality and would be for most teams, is now no longer a discussion point. Thank god.

LISTEN: FYP Podcast EXTRAAA - Palace finally win without Wilf Zaha

Worldy Star

The match winner was an absolute banger from Luka Milivojevic, curling it into the bottom corner from 25-yards out giving Kasper Schmeichel no chance. It was only Palace's third goal from open play at Selhurst Park this season, the other two being a fluke and another banger against Burnley.

It reinforces the worry that apart from penalties and worldies, Palace don't actually score or even look like scoring many normal goals. Each time they go forward it's hard to feel like they are going to create decent chances and put it in the net.

Jordan Ayew certainly put himself about on Saturday and arguably had his best game for Palace, winning some flick ons and making some intelligent runs in behind (even though he was called offside for a few of them). But even when he does get into decent positions you just never feel like he will score or that Palace are a threat going forward. That has to change.

What a Guai

Palace fans finally got to see January signing Vicente Guaita in between the sticks for a league game, five months after he arrived in South London. And it was worth the wait as he put in a very sturdy, and entertaining, display.

In truth he didn't have a lot to do in what was a frankly slog of a game but two big moments stood out. He was 'fouled' by Jamie Vardy trying to play the ball with his feet in the first half and got away with what really was a soft foul.

However, he denied the Leicester no.9 in some style late on with a save low down to his left that rebounded off the post into his grateful arms. A little tap in thanks to the post and a cheery post-match interview in broken English has only endeared him to Palace fans more. That, and the fact he isn't Wayne Hennessey.

Kelly-vision

Another player who filled in on Saturday was perennial backup Martin Kelly, who played in the place of the suspended James Tomkins at centre-back. He was arguably Man of the Match with an imperious display alongside Mama Sakho.

Kelly has come a long way from the days where he asked not to be played at left-back by Alan Pardew because he was getting torn apart so regularly and while he may not be a starter he always seems to do a job when called upon.

Back in his natural position of centre-back he was an absolute rock, keeping Vardy quiet and winning almost everything in the air. He probably deserves to keep his place in the team next week too.

Roy Story

It was only a week ago fans were calling for Roy's head but funny how they have gone quiet on social media after that professional, if unexciting, victory over Leicester.

That's now two home wins on the bounce and no goals conceded, in fact it's three games unbeaten at home in the last four and that was only cos Jordan Ayew bottled a header against Spurs.

Things aren't quite as bad as the doom and gloom merchants on Twitter will have you believe and Hodgson and Palace have a history of turning things around. January will be a big month but there are plenty of signs from Saturday that the season could pan out nicely again.